As is widely known in this era when so many of us are buying and upgrading older boats, there’s not much gear on a sailboat that doesn’t eventually need replacement.
Consider foredeck hatches. Seemingly made to last forever, hatches fall prey to broken hinges, fractured or worn-out dogs, bent locking mechanisms, lost knobs and to the deterioration of the adhesives, caulking and gaskets that make them waterproof. They also succumb to spinnaker poles, whisker poles and anchors, all of which behave like hatch-seeking Sidewinder missiles.
We recall a popular 19′ 2″, twoberth cruising boat that in its early production versions had a hatch attached with two small hinges whose little machine screws sheered easily when the hatch was leaned on while handing a jib. If you had one of these boats, you know the name. The boat, now a four-berth model, still is being produced, improved by the simple elimination of the forward hatch.
If it is merely the acrylic insert in the hatch that is scratched or crazed (common) or cracked (uncommon), replacing the “lens,” as it is called in the trade, is not difficult. On most hatches, a simple, hard razor cut frees the lens. Clean the channel and lay in a bead of the adhesive supplied with the replacement lens, usually a chem ical adhesive called “Silpruf,” made by the Silicone Products Division of General Electric. Then, press home the new panel and clean up the edges. The principal bond takes place between the edge of the lens and the frame.
It may seem strange to have something as im portant as a hatch lens mere lyglued inplace, without mechanical fasteners. However, no hatch maker to whom we talked has ever had a “lens” pop out by accident. We’ve never heard of it happening.
If you like to spend money and want even greater (but probably unnecessary) strength, get a Lexan lens with a Margard finish to hard-glaze the surface. Moby Dick can land on it, without mishap.
Finding a replacement for a hatch damaged beyond repair can be difficult, especially if, as is often the case, it was custom made by a boat builder now out of business, or if you have a cambered mounting surface. The retrofit is much simplified if the manu facturer of your boat used stock hatch es still being produced.
The key to avoiding extra work and expense is finding a hatch that fits the original opening in the deck. Luckily, most hatch makers make relatively standard-sized hatches. If the mounting holes match, it’s a bonus, but don’t count on it. Also, the radius on the corners of the hatch base must be approximately the same. And, finally, you must decide if you need a flush-deck or spigot model. The spigot is a flange on the base that extends down into the deck opening. The interior then can be finished off easily with an optional trim ring to which a screen (if available) may be attached.
Whatever kind of hatch you choose or are forced to choose, a first-rate foredeck hatch has a lot of priority when you take solid water over the bow. An absolutely watertight hatch also avoids a serious annoyance factor for those who sleep in the forward berths.
For these reasons, we selected for this evaluation top-of-the-line hatch es from nine major suppliers. Most manufacturers make hatches in a number of sizes and shapes, including low-profile models. We arbitrarily chose a square size–for a deck opening of 19″ x 19″.
Hatch Manufacturers
The world’s largest producer of aluminum hatches, both cast and extruded, the Bomar Company, in New Hampshire, makes more than 90 percent of all powerboat hatches and used to have an equally lopsided share of the sailboat market. Bomar offers many models, sizes and shapes, in cluding round, trapezoidal and one with acurved base for cambered decks.
Lewmar, increasingly aggressive in recent years with a wide range of highly-engineered extruded hatches, has cut severely into the sailboat hatch market. Bomar is fighting back, but the big British company, well represented in the United States by IM in Connecticut, means business.
Another player in this lively scrap is an old-line Canadian company, Atkins & Hoyle. It’s knowledgeable CEO, Eric Atkins, takes pride in its excellent hatches that are, like Bomar’s, cast in Almag 35, a light-weight aluminum-magnesium alloy with great strength.
And determined not to be left behind is Nicro Marine, which imports a line called Moonlight hatches, frequently seen with Nicro’s popular Day and Night Solar Vents mounted in the lens. The hatches are made by the respected Sophus Berendsen company in Denmark.
Goiot, the French hatch manufacturer (owned by Beneteau), is trying for a place in the American market, but has had no U.S. representative since Welborn Marine in Florida dropped Goiot at the “suggestion” of Ronstan, the Australian marine gear maker. The Goiot hatch in this evaluation came directly from France.
Vetus, a Dutch manufacturer with an excellent U.S. representative (Vetus-Denoudenin Baltimore, Maryland), continues to have difficulty in its effort to carveoutaniche. (Another Dutch company, Randal, represented by Norseman Marine in Florida, makes only custom hatches.) Better known for its portlights, BecksonMarine, of Bridgeport, Connecticut, makes a limited range of plastic hatches, and Nelson Taylor Company (“Taylor-Made”). in Gloversville, New York, offers but one hatch (in five sizes).
(The California firm, Forespar, known primarily for its poles, life saving gear and Marelon® plumbing fittings, said it is getting out of the hatchbusiness. Because its Marelon® framed hatch, still shown in its 1994 catalog, will be dropped next year, we did not include it in our evaluation.)
Finally, pretty much in a special category, is the heavyweight stainless steel hatch sold by Hood Yacht Systems in Portsmouth, Rhode Island. (Hood was purchased by Bomar in late March.)
Specs: Deck Hatches
Price List/ Manufacturer Model Discount* | Weight (lbs.) | Material | Lens | Opening | Hinge | Dogs | Screens | Inside Trim | Comments |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alkins & Hoyle XR Double Frame $745/N.A. | 16 | Cast aluminum | Acrylic | 150° | Part of casting, spring-assisted | Spring-loaded, adjustable | No | No | In basic black without options: $450. Optional friction hinges. |
Beckson H-1 $225/N.A. | 8.25 | ABS Plastic | None | 80° | Small riveted | Part of support arms | No | No | Domed top is fairly strong. Base lacks screw holes. Light duty. |
Bomar 139LO (lever operated) 605/$400 | 20 | Cast aluminum | Lexan | 120° | Part of casting | Spring-loaded, adjustable | No | No | Has most extensive line of hatches, many sizes and options. |
Goiot Cristal $757/N.A. | 18 | Cast lid, extruded base | Acrylic | 180° | Friction, spring-assisted | Adjustable tension | Yes | Yes | Offers many options and finishes, but is difficult to install. |
Hood $837/N.A. | 21 | Extruded stainless steel | Acrylic | 180° | Welded | Spring-loaded, adjustable | No | N.A. | Welding is crude, very heavy to open and lock in place. |
Lewmar Ocean $512/$400 | 12.5 | Extruded | Acrylic | 180° | Friction, spring-assisted | Inside-outside opening, adjustable | Yes | Yes | Like Bomar, offers many models, finishes and many options. |
Nicro Offshore $664/$529 | 14.5 | Extruded | Acrylic | 180° | Mechanically fastened, friction | Inside-outside opening, adjustable | Yes | Yes | Excellent tubular gasket and the best friction hinges. |
Taylor $338/N.A. | 15 | Extruded | Acrylic | 100° | Welded | Part of support arms | Yes | Yes | Cleverly engineered for low price, but not a heavy-duty hatch. |
Vetus Libero $530/N.A. | 18 | Extruded | Acrylic | goo | Mechanically fastened | Held in stops | Yes | Yes | Good Dutch engineering, soundly manufactured, many options. |
The Evaluation
Several general observations apply to hatches. They’re not simple devices. The choice is made even more difficult by the bewildering variety offered by the manufacturers.
Cast aluminum hatches, although heavier and more expensive, general ly are considered better than those made of extruded aluminum. Cast hatches provide the rigidity needed to get a good mating between the deck and the hatch base and also between the base and the hatch lid. Cast hatch es also have integral hinge “ears” and good dog mounts, all part of the casting (which makes unnecessary any holes in the lens).
On hatches made of extruded aluminum, hydraulically bent to shape, the hinges and other fittings must be attached with rivets or other fasteners to the extruded frame or the lens. All such holes are potential leak points. Extruded hatch bases, unless made of very heavy structural shapes, can flex at the deck, break the seal and result in leaks, especially on offshore boats that take aboard solid water. Unlike cast hatches, extruded hatches have butt seams that must be welded or sealed with tape (usually secured under a hinge). The frame finish is important. Unless very carefully maintained, stainless steel will deteriorate in time, especially at the weldments. Although initially very handsome, powder-coated aluminum (black or white) tends, sooner or later, to flake off. Black anodizing often discolors in saltwater. The longest-lasting finish is clear anodized aluminum (about a 10-percent premium, but worth it). Extruded aluminum is easy to anodize. The cheapest is “strip anodized,” which means the long extrusions are formed and anodized in one continuous operation. As long as the extrusion die (a two- or sometimes three-piece, hand made assembly that can cost upwards of $5,000) is very well made, strip anodizing can be very handsome. As used on hatches, “piece anodizing,” which coats the end cuts against corrosion, is somewhat more expensive. Most expensive is anodized cast aluminum, because the castings must be laboriously polished before anodizing.
The all-important waterproof seal strip (called the gasket) can be closed cell foam, which tends to compress in time; an extruded lip-type seal insert ed in the aluminum extrusion, which is better but can be difficult to replace; or, best of all, a round- or box-shaped tube, with an air space that “rests” the tube when the hatch is open. Whatever elastomer is used, it should have minimal shrink. If the gasket shrinks where the ends butt, the resulting tiny crack may produce that not serious but annoying leak.
Hinges are interesting. Some open to about 90 degrees; others open 180 degrees, flat on the deck (which may be desirable if there ‘s room or if you often rig a fabric wind scoop). The trend is to spring-loaded hinges, to make the hatch easier to lift open. Lewmar, Goiot and Nicro hatches (and one Atkins & Hoyle model) have adjustable friction hinges that hold the hatch in position, dispensing with support arms that can be clumsy to secure with little tightening knobs. The new friction hinges, usually adjusted with Allen wrenches, do require occasional maintenance to avoid the problem with earlier versions that simply wore loose and left you with a flopping hatch lid.
Bomar and Atkins & Hoyle offer excellent hatches, with two sets of “gudgeons” to reverse the “pintles,” to make the hatch open either forward (in the customary manner) or aft. They are very desirable on boats in tropical weather. Goiot also has a two-way hatch with a patented system that dispenses with conventional hinges and opens either way without repositioning a hinge pin.
For the ultimate refinements, Goiot offers on its hatches an optional “opening detector,” an electrical connection wired to a panel light to indicate that the hatch is locked, and Lewmar, in addition to a choice of clear, white, smoke gray, bronze, slip-resistant or light-weight honeycomb lenses (for the weight-conscious ocean racer), offers an optional key lock to secure any of its hatches.
Locking dogs, another trouble spot (they can break when somebody on deck slams the hatch with the dogs in the wrong position), also have been greatly improved. The dogs, usually glass-filled nylon, have larger handles, usually tensioned with spacers and tightening bolts to keep them snug. Another recent innovation on some models by Bomar, Lewmar, Goiotand Vetus are dogs that can be operated from on deck. It’s handy to be able to open the hatch from on deck. However, this innovation required the development of an interior locking system and exterior “breakaway” handles to thwart would-be burglars.
Whereas older hatches rarely had screens, some (but not all) hatches now come with well-engineered screens that fasten neatly and positively to a trim ring. A trim ring and screen usually is an option costing about $100 to $150. The screens still must be removed to open and close the hatch and are just as prone to being torn or bent when you forget the screen is in place when you stuff a jib down the hatch.
To reduce the possibility, when coming about, of snagging the hatch with a foresail sheet (a common problem with hatches mounted on raised boxes), all hatch manufacturers have, in recent years, given close attention to designing hatches with rounded corners and smooth hardware.
The Bottom Line
In your choice of a replacement hatch, the choice may be dictated by the need for a good fit. All the hatch manufacturers have good “spec sheets” that, together with your careful measurements, will nominate the “possibilities.” Your choice also should take into account the kind of sailing you do. Nobody would cross the ocean with a plastic Beckson fore hatch; we don’t think Beckson would recommend that you do so. By the same token, having a top-of-the-line cast hatch on a small inland lake weekender might be considered overkill.
Therefore, the following assessments are to help winnow down the choices as you study each company’s catalogs.
For the ultimate hatch, Bomar’s top-of-the-line all-cast hatch with a Lexanlens stands out. It’s a no-nonsense power house, very desirable if you intend to do ocean work in heavy weather.
If you want a very strong con ventional hatch, the Atkins & Hoyle Model XR hatch, also all cast aluminum, with double opening hinges, anoptional extra thick acrylic lens and a clear anodized finish, also is an excellent choice. Because Atkins & Hoyle hatches are not offered at discount, they are ex pensive.
If you want the convenience of standard adjustable tension hinges and inside-outside dogs with locks and optional fitted screens that snap into trim rings, consider Nicro’s very fine Offshore hatch or the very sleek and modern Lewmar Ocean line.
For less money and easy replacement, Lewmar’s Coastline models or Bomar’s new “CRX” models and “Nibo” line (either high or low profile), both with trim rings and fitted screens, would be good choices. The Nibo line comes in 15 sizes.
A decent hatch with reasonable quality and an excellent price, the Taylor hatch makes sense, if you can obtain a “fit” from the company’s limited number of sizes.